decission

[wkssmiley]

i need some help with deciding on the right flute to purchase for my daughter
i am looking at the gemeinhardt 33, armstrong 800b and the emerson ef8b

could you please give me an idea which would be the better choice?

this is so confussing.

thanks
sheila

[FluteMonkey]

It sounds like you're looking at an intermediate flute for your daughter. If she is at an intermediate level then she has enough experience to try out some of these flutes and participate in the decision. I'd suggest that you take her to a flute dealer that has the models in stock and have her give them each a good try. If she has a flute teacher or knows an experienced adult flute player, invite them along to help. The models you mention are common intermediate flutes, but if the dealer has other options available, definitely give them a try.

You can find some really good articles on many flute topics at www.jennifercluff.com as well as her recommendations for brands. I also have several articles about buying a flute on my site www.flutemonkey.com.

Happy flute shopping!

[fluteguy18]

From a manufacturer's standpoint (or a retailers as well) the Emerson and the Armstrong are practically identical flutes when you strip them down (they're both made by the Conn-Selmer company). Ultimately these flutes are all mass produced, machine made flutes that won't be a significant step up in the end from what she is using right now (most likely).

I would recommend looking at other brands like Azumi, Avanti, Galway Spirit flutes, Sonare, Brio, Jupiter DiMedici, and Pearl. Most of these companies offer similarly priced models but with considerably better results from a handcut headjoint (and various other specifications).

I also recommend taking a look at the FAQ on this message board. There's a lot of information there. I agree with the advice of working with a teacher through the process. Furthermore I would contact flute retailers about setting up a trial. The largest companies like Carolyn Nussbaum Music Company, Flute Specialists Inc. and Fluteworld will send you flutes to try for a nominal fee (usually shipping cost and then a credit card number to charge the flute to if you decide to purchase one).