Hamming or Burkart & Phelan piccolo?
Moderators: Classitar, pied_piper, Phineas
Hamming or Burkart & Phelan piccolo?
Hi, I am new here . I am considering to upgrade my piccolo (yamaha 62) and would like to see for advice. Does anyone try the Hamming 650/2, Burkart & Phelan and Global piccolo before? These brand seems have good reputation in the world. Are they really easy to go to highest "C"? Since I am living in a small city - Hong Kong, and we only have the Yamaha here... !
Sorry about the delayed response...
Both brands you mention are fine although you never know with hand-made instruments. I do not have an instrument endorsement but I play a Hammig 650/2 and I love it (and anyone borrowing it does too). I had played on a borrowed Burkart before several times, and the two piccs were very similar. However, I thought the Hammig had a nicer tone in the bottom register and had a slightly better scale. But again, that's just me, and it was a trial of 2 instruments, and it's only my opinion of the actual instruments I tried. So don't take this comment of mine blindly.
It is tricky to buy a flute/picc without trying it first, though. I'd suggest that you try them both out first. Hopefully you can do that without having to commit to buying.
Both brands you mention are fine although you never know with hand-made instruments. I do not have an instrument endorsement but I play a Hammig 650/2 and I love it (and anyone borrowing it does too). I had played on a borrowed Burkart before several times, and the two piccs were very similar. However, I thought the Hammig had a nicer tone in the bottom register and had a slightly better scale. But again, that's just me, and it was a trial of 2 instruments, and it's only my opinion of the actual instruments I tried. So don't take this comment of mine blindly.
It is tricky to buy a flute/picc without trying it first, though. I'd suggest that you try them both out first. Hopefully you can do that without having to commit to buying.
Boglarka
Kiss - Fluteland.com Teacher
Kiss - Fluteland.com Teacher