Need a New Flute After 24 Years!

Flute History and Instrument Purchase

Moderators: Classitar, pied_piper, Phineas

Post Reply
User avatar
ljjones
Posts: 5
Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2004 7:02 am
Location: Gloucester, Virginia

Need a New Flute After 24 Years!

Post by ljjones »

I have been playing flute for 30 years and have had my current flute for 24 years. It is an old Gemeinhardt and has served me very well :) , but I am ready to buy a new flute and have been looking at different brands. I would like one that is pretty good quality. 8) I am an intermediate to moderately advanced player and I would like to invest in a high quality flute for the rest of my playing career. I have about $8,000 to spend, but I know I don't necessarily need to spend that much to get a flute that I will really like. One I am especially interested in is the Miyazawa brand (solid silver, hand-made, B-foot, E-Mech). Does anyone have experience or knowledge of this Japanese brand? Is it a good brand? What other brands do you recommend for me? Also, for all the years I have been playing, I never had an open-holed flute. :oops: When I buy the new instrument, it will most likely be open-hole because that is what is most prevalent and preferred amongst the higher-end flutes. Of course, at least at first, I will need to use the plugs to put in the keys to be able to play it. But has anyone else tried to learn to play open-hole for the first time after playing for many years on plateau, and were you successful? How hard was it to learn (and unlearn the fingering positions you were used to)? My fingering positions have gotten kind of sloppy over the years, and I am just wondering what it will be like to try to learn to play open-hole :?: Thanks!
"Make a joyful noise unto the Lord!"

MeLizzard
Posts: 462
Joined: Tue Dec 10, 2002 10:25 pm
Location: Mid-Ohio Valley

Need a new flute after 24 years!

Post by MeLizzard »

Hi ! Wow, $8,000 is a good deal to be able to spend! You'll have overwhelming choices at this amount. Just be sure to play a lot of different flutes, at music stores, conventions, through dealers such as Flute World, etc. For decades, there was Haynes and there was Powell; now there are many smaller, more independent flutemakers out there with great products. I don't have LOTS of experience with Miyazawa, but they seem to have a lighter, brighter tone compared to some other models. I play Muramatsu, which seems great across its entire range, nice rich color palette and fast mechanism, even in the lower-priced models. Try some Yamahas for fun, some of these are nice, depending what options you prefer (I like these with heavy wall). Sometimes these are a little overpriced compared to similar-playing models. Also, maybe look at Powell, Altus, Tom Green (nice handmade flutes, in Michigan, I think), Trevor James; all kinds of flutes out here! :D As well, open-hole is not a requirement for a "professional" flute. Plateau keys are available from really any flutemaker, if this is what you prefer. Another consideration is inline vs. offset G key. Though I'm accustomed to my inline G, with very long fingers, many professional players are opting for offset Gs to avoid tension + repetitive-use injuries from long hours of practice. There are also theories that the offset configuration allows faster technique. Take your time and pick out just the right flute. Happy shopping!! :)

User avatar
ljjones
Posts: 5
Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2004 7:02 am
Location: Gloucester, Virginia

Re: Need a new flute after 24 years!

Post by ljjones »

MeLizzard wrote:Just be sure to play a lot of different flutes, at music stores, conventions, through dealers such as Flute World, etc.

MeLizzard: Thanks a lot for the suggestions. I am planning a trip to visit the dealer J. L. Smith and Co. in Charlotte, NC, in October to try out their inventory of flutes. I have seen some of their flutes at flute faires, but it was kind of hard to try them out in that setting, and also they did not have plugs for the keys, so I couldn't really test them very well since I only play plateau style currently. :( J. L. Smith is the only flute specialty store anywhere near where I live. There are no music stores nearby that I would trust with this kind of thing. I would rather drive 6 hours to a flute specialty store like J. L. Smith than to a music store around the corner.

Do you have any experience with J. L. Smith and Co. :?: They appear to be a very good flute specialty company that does a lot of their own custom work, etc., they appear to have an excellent selection, and I love their honesty and integrity which shows in everything they do. Check them out at http://www.flutesmith.com/. I don't want to use their trial program where they will send you flutes to try out, because I feel like I will need to try out a LOT of flutes and I don't want to be tied to just a few that they send me to test, and I don't really want to go to all the trouble to do trials from several different dealers. To me, making a weekend flute shopping trip is much easier and more enjoyable, plus I will have an excellent opportunity to get expert advice from their flute specialists while I am there. Of course, they will want to sell me one of THEIR flutes, and I will go realizing that, but in my experience with them at the flute faires, they do not apply pressure tactics to sell their products or the most expensive flutes. In fact, they have warned me and others at the faires to avoid thinking that the more I spend, the better the flute I will get, and also to try out many flutes before making a selection. People need to pay more attention to overall quality of the instrument, value for the money, and "best fit" for their needs when selecting a flute, and that is what J. L. Smith tells people. In short, I am confident that I can get an excellent flute from them that will be perfect FOR ME and my needs. :lol: What do you think of my plan?

P.S. Anyone else is welcome to chime in to this discussion as well if you have something to add. Thanks!
"Make a joyful noise unto the Lord!"

MeLizzard
Posts: 462
Joined: Tue Dec 10, 2002 10:25 pm
Location: Mid-Ohio Valley

Post by MeLizzard »

Sounds like a plan! I don't have experience with this company; let us know how it works out. Happy shopping :D

hunter
Posts: 10
Joined: Fri Jan 31, 2003 5:45 pm

Need a new flute

Post by hunter »

Recently, I was looking to purchase a new headjoint for my Gemeinhardt flute. Upon researching headjoints, and getting opinions from Fluteland.com forums, I decided to purchase a new Trevor James flute. I live near Raleigh, NC, so I decided to drive to Charlotte. I visited J.L. Smith Company in Charlotte, NC this past weekend (9/11). It is a wonderful historic home in downtown Charlotte that happens to be a music store. I have never been in a music store that sold high level professional instruments. The staff was very helpful and knowledgable. When you walk into the store, the "flute room" is on the right of the foyer and the rest of the instruments are in the room to the left of the foyer. The store has hardwood floors throughout. I was able to try six different Trevor James flutes. Now, I will tell you my reason for going with the Trevor James. I am an amateur adult flute player. I did not want to spend more than $1,500, but I wanted to get the most bang for my buck. I purchased the Trevor James Cantabile flute w/ the solid hand-cut headjoint, silver-plated body, off-set G, open hole, b-foot, e-mechanism. I am sooooooo happy with the sound of this flute. The scale is very good on it. The sound and very open and clear. Please pull up the website to see the rest of the selection of flutes. The store does offer to ship different flutes to your home to try, but in my opinion it is worth the trip to Charlotte, NC to be able to try as many flutes as possible. My experience there was so wonderful. I cannot stop smiling every time I think of the experience and my flute. Good luck! By the way, I am a Newport News, VA native!

biggzh
Posts: 51
Joined: Sun Oct 10, 2004 4:50 pm

Post by biggzh »

you could get a handmade one. There are small dealers in Indianapolis and other major cities that do make flutes by hand for a living. If you're pretty good with your high-e by now, I don't think you'd need a split-e mechanism.

Post Reply